The Minuses of a Plus Without Phones
New Policy Bans Phones in the Library
January 10, 2017
A new policy that started at the beginning of this year is banning the distractions of cellphone use in the RHS library. The only technology that can be utilized in the library are chromebooks, as the computers have been removed this year.
According to a survey at the beginning of the year, 28.57% of students prefer to do their homework at school or in the library, meaning that almost a third of them would choose to crank out an outline at school rather than in the comforts of their own homes.
This is a sizeable portion of students wishing to get a proactive start on their homework, but the inconvenience of not being allowed access to their phones in the library has left many perturbed.
In doing their homework, 73.97% of students use their phone either almost always or always. The access to research on phones is much easier than pulling up a slow computer or flipping through the pages of a book.
Technology is the path of the future, yet 53.11% of students surveyed believe there is either not enough accessible technology for them to be successful, or teachers do not allow them to use it often enough as is needed.
However, even though phones are still fairly restricted at school and especially in the library, one must not overlook administrative efforts to provide us with easily accessible chromebooks. They have even replaced the old computers built into the library with a chrome cart made obtainable through an exchange of your ID.
Administrative efforts to restrict phone usage during school only cripples students heading out into the real world, a world defined by the ever-present need to effectively utilize technology.
If the fear is that cell phones might distract, the simple truth is when students enter their future careers, those distractions will not just merely disappear. We need to learn now how to manage these distractions for ourselves, instead of having authoritarian figures do it for us.
Mr. Katz • Jan 20, 2017 at 10:43 am
Well written article, a few points of view from the library. We didn’t remove or replace the 8 floor computers, the district had them moved to the back side cubicles in the library for students to be able to print in the kiosks for more privacy. We offer 40 chrome books that a student can check out anytime to be able to work in the library to do any school work. The phone ban in the Library was needed for the reason that the Library was becoming a social meeting place with over 80 plus students before school, at break, and at lunch, creating a very load and crowded atmosphere (similar to the cafeteria) not allowing the students that needed to study and get work done in a more quite study hall atmosphere. By banning phones the students that just came in socially not to work now won’t come in to “play” making the Library a nice quit study hall the way a Library should be, with enough computers and Chrome books to get any of students work done. Would have liked to have Mr. Murphy get our opinion also for the article to share these thoughts. Thank you.